ALIENATED
2023 · 3m
Directed by Asher Borison
Genres: animation, coming-of-age, sci-fi
Tones: melancholic, tender
An alien girl is bullied in middle school.
Picked by Zoe
The scouts
The alien-as-metaphor-for-alienation premise is exactly the kind of obvious emotional shorthand that usually makes me want to leave the theater, but Borison's restraint—refusing to weaponize the sci-fi wrapping for easy pathos—actually lands as quietly subversive.
A formally precise animation that understands the lineage of outsider narratives in coming-of-age cinema; the melancholic tone is sustained with admirable discipline, though the conceit risks settling into familiar territory without enough formal disruption to justify its three-minute length.
The decisive move here is the color palette—those muted, desaturated blues and grays that make the alien girl visually *match* the emotional landscape of middle school rather than contrast against it—a single chromatic choice that collapses the distance between metaphor and experience.