Con ánimo de lucro
2006 · 32m · España
Directed by Joan Planas
Genres: documentary, essay film
Tones: contemplative, provocative
This documentary examines poverty in the first and third worlds through NGOs, television, education, politics and religion, questioning the Millennium Goals and proposing an alternative.
Picked by Margot
The scouts
The Millennium Goals deconstruction is solid ideological jujitsu, but the film plays it too straight—it reads like a well-argued op-ed when it could've been weird and broken about it, let the contradictions actually breathe instead of narrating them into submission.
Planas situates himself squarely in the essay-documentary lineage of Marker and Godard, where montage becomes argument; the formal architecture—how poverty footage, institutional rhetoric, and counter-narratives are woven—does the intellectual work that mere talking points never could.
The decision to let contradictions sit unresolved rather than resolve them rhetorically is what sells this; most docs would hammer the conclusion, but Planas trusts the viewer enough to leave the frame deliberately fractured, and that restraint is what makes the provocation actually land.