El crimen desorganizado

2012 · 16m · España

Directed by Stephan Hofmann

Genres: comedy, crime, satire

Tones: absurdist, darkly comic, humorous

Five would-be gangsters with family obligations and no time, money or transport cannot agree on how to rob a casino, and finally consider asking the bank for a loan instead.

Picked by Felix

The scouts

A heist film that refuses to heist—five incompetent would-be criminals negotiating a bank loan instead of robbing a casino is exactly the kind of premise that makes people groan until they realize it's the only honest thing about crime cinema. Hofmann's not interested in the fantasy; he's interested in what actually breaks the genre's back: logistics, family, and the bureaucratic humiliation of having to ask permission.

Felix

The film's restraint—its refusal to escalate beyond the planning table—recalls a lineage of deadpan European absurdism, though the execution feels slight for what it attempts; the tonal control is there, but the formal architecture needed to elevate this from concept-sketch to considered work isn't quite present.

Margot

The decision to shoot this entirely in the mundane spaces of bureaucratic failure—parking lots, kitchen tables, bank offices—rather than cut between aspiration and reality gives the whole thing its nervous energy; it's a single formal choice that makes the joke land where a conventional crime-comedy setup would've deflated it.

Zoe