Formaldehyde
2019 · 12m
Directed by David Swinburne
Genres: crime, drama, thriller
Tones: contemplative, dark, surreal
What looks like a formulaic cop procedural at a brutal crime scene becomes something stranger in this crime drama.
Picked by Felix
The scouts
A cop procedural that plays you straight for twelve minutes before yanking the rug out—this is the kind of bait-and-switch that actually earns its twist because Swinburne commits fully to the genre grammar before fracturing it. Most scouts would've filed this under 'thriller'; Felix sees a subversive sleight of hand that shouldn't work but does.
Swinburne demonstrates formal precision in the crime-scene setup, establishing visual and narrative conventions with the control of someone fluent in procedural language—the payoff hinges on the viewer's internalized expectations of the form. It's a formally literate film that understands what it's deconstructing.
The shift from procedural to surreal lives or dies on a single editorial or performance choice—the moment the familiar breaks—and Swinburne makes that pivot land through what feels like a calculated constraint rather than chaos, which is the mark of a filmmaker who knows exactly what they're doing with minimal means.
Reviews
It's all very procedural and formulaic in a way that screams "episodic cop drama." But, before you eject, stick with it. The familiarity has a way of lulling you into complacency so that when the film reveals its true premise about 3 minutes in, it's hard not to be hooked.
On a basic level, Formaldehyde is a pitch for a longer movie we don't get to see (Swinburne and his writing partner Garrett Detrixhe have a feature length version already written), and that's somewhat disappointing. But, the formal high-concept is engaging and the overall tone and technical execution is top notch.
I really like how Swinburne and Detrixhe take what easily could be a cheesy USA Network premise and handles it with maturity and weight. It's a piece as much about loneliness, isolation, and voyeurism as it is about the morbid high concept.