Goodnight, Mister Stalin
2024 · 20m · United Kingdom
Directed by Benjamin Kodboel
Genres: documentary, essay film, historical
Tones: contemplative, melancholic, tender
Two friends in Gori, Georgia — one who reveres Stalin and one who despises him — debate his contested legacy.
Picked by Margot
The scouts
Everyone expects a Stalin doc to pick a side; Kodboel's refusal to let either friend 'win' feels almost cowardly until you realize he's actually dismantling the whole debate format itself — the real subversion is in what he doesn't resolve.
This sits perfectly in the essay-film tradition of Marker and Farocki, where intimate conversation becomes a formal apparatus for historical reckoning; the melancholy restraint of the editing mirrors the film's own refusal of easy answers, placing it in a lineage of morally serious nonfiction.
The choice to keep both voices equally weighted and never cut away from the genuine affection between these two men, even as they argue over atrocity — that's the decision that transforms this from a debate into something about friendship itself, and it's what makes 20 minutes feel complete.