Hipótesis
2011 · 4m · España
Directed by Roberto Goñi
Tones: humorous, provocative
Julio tests his girlfriend with an innocent hypothetical question — whether she would rather he spent a night with Scarlett Johansson — and the game turns into an unexpected dilemma.
Picked by Felix
The scouts
A premise that looks like a cutesy couple's game and then *refuses* to stay there — the hypothetical becomes a trap, the joke becomes a confession, and the whole thing implodes with beautiful awkwardness. Four minutes of people realizing they don't actually know what they agreed to.
Clean, economical construction in the tradition of relationship comedies that use constraint as form—the single-room setting and real-time structure echo mid-century theatrical farce, though Goñi's tone sits somewhere between Rohmer and contemporary unease.
The entire film hinges on the actress's micro-expressions in the silence after the question lands—that moment where she realizes this isn't playful anymore and the performance shifts from flirtation to calculation, and suddenly we're watching something honest instead of cute.