"I Don't Think It's Meant for Us ..."
1971 · 32m · Canada
Directed by Kathleen Shannon
Genres: documentary, essay film
Tones: contemplative, provocative
Public housing tenants describe how federal, provincial and municipal housing policies affect their daily lives, voicing conflicting views on the systems that govern their homes.
Picked by Margot
The scouts
Shannon does something genuinely disruptive here—she doesn't resolve the contradiction, just lets competing voices sit in the frame like an argument that refuses closure, which should feel didactic but somehow doesn't.
A formally rigorous essay documentary that understands its lineage in the Canadian direct cinema tradition while pushing against it; the decision to let conflicting testimonies remain unreconciled is both structurally precise and philosophically honest.
The architectural choice to cut between tenants' monologues without explanatory voiceover creates this tension where the viewer has to hold multiple truths at once—it's a production decision that costs nothing but demands everything from the audience.