Night Watches Us
2024 · 42m · Canada
Directed by Stefan Verna
Genres: documentary, essay film
Tones: contemplative, melancholic, tender
After 23-year-old Nicholas Gibbs is killed by Montreal police, his family and community grieve together and press for answers about the forces that led to his death.
Picked by Margot
The scouts
A grief film about police violence—the subject matter reads like consensus-building, but Verna's essay-doc structure resists the expected catharsis; there's something genuinely unsettling about how tenderly it withholds easy answers, which is the only reason I'm not bored.
Verna situates this squarely in the lineage of Astra Taylor and the contemporary essay-documentary form, where montage and voice become arguments about witnessing itself—the 42 minutes feel architecturally considered, each formal choice a statement about what cinema owes to grief and accountability.
The singular move here is how Verna uses silence and negative space between community voices, letting the gaps become the film itself rather than padding; it's a micro-budget film that understands that one cut in the right place does the work of a dozen explanatory shots.