Quizás sí, quizás no

2024 · 4m · España

Directed by María de Miguel

Genres: musical, romance

Tones: contemplative, tender

During a car trip, a couple enjoys the beginning of their holidays, the landscape and the music, which becomes the perfect soundtrack for these three minutes in their lives.

Picked by Zoe

The scouts

Four minutes of couple-enjoys-drive-with-good-music sounds like the kind of Hallmark premise that makes me want to scream, but I suspect de Miguel's doing something quietly subversive with the form—the fact that I can't quite articulate what bugs me about it means she's already won.

Felix

There's a lineage of cinema-about-cinema hiding in this film—the way music and landscape become narrative structure rather than accompaniment places it in conversation with the French New Wave's meditative traditions, though de Miguel seems to be refining rather than referencing.

Margot

The entire film hinges on one decision: trusting the music and the road to do the emotional labor instead of forcing a plot, and that restraint—that specific choice to let three minutes breathe—is what transforms a rom-com premise into something that actually lands.

Zoe