Rosa - These Storms
2016 · 11m
Directed by Hannah Gregg, Sean Kusanagi
Genres: coming-of-age, documentary
Tones: contemplative, provocative, tender
In a rural Guatemalan village where girls drop out of school to help at home, Rosa Coj Bocel asks why she didn't get to go to school, launching a journey toward independence.
Picked by Zoe
The scouts
This is exactly the kind of film that *looks* like consensus-approved do-goodery on the surface—rural Guatemala, girls' education, the whole thing—but Rosa's refusal to perform gratitude or inspiration actually subverts the entire white-savior documentary tradition; Gregg and Kusanagi let her be petulant, ambivalent, real, which is genuinely radical for the genre.
The film's formal restraint—its willingness to sit with Rosa's silences and let the landscape breathe—places it squarely in the tradition of observational documentary that trusts its subject over narrative manipulation; the editing rhythm of everyday moments building toward quiet self-determination feels descended from the best of Cinema Vérité.
The single choice that makes this work is the sound design: the ambient weight of rural life—roosters, wind, domestic labor—never gets sentimentalized or swept under a score, which means when Rosa's voice cuts through, asking her question, it *lands* with an intimacy that costs almost nothing to achieve but everything to get right.
Reviews
Living On One's Rosa – These Storms joins that conversation with a powerfully raw documentary about Rosa Coj Bocel. This is one of those films that will take you on a very emotional journey and probably leave your face an embarrassing mess of liquid.
Rosa asks the poignant question to camera: "why didn't I get to go to school?" This passion for wanting more and recognizing the unfairness of her situation launches her on a journey toward adulthood and independence.
They lived with her for weeks during the filming of their feature film Living On One Dollar and for this particular film they let Rosa, who also stars in the feature doc, tell her own story. In many ways, this film was Rosa's outlet for not only moving on from her own hardships, but a way to encourage other girls around the world to overcome even the most extreme difficulties.