Stolen Treasure

2024 · 4m

Directed by Emma Bliese

Genres: adventure, animation, fantasy

Tones: theatrical, whimsical

A girl with a secret or two sails aboard a pirate ship.

Picked by Zoe

The scouts

A girl-on-a-pirate-ship premise is almost aggressively conventional—but if Bliese found the angle that subverts it, the whimsy here might actually be doing something weirder than it looks on paper.

Felix

The theatrical tone suggests a film aware of its own artifice; the real question is whether the animation carries formal intention or just whimsy, and whether Bliese situates this in the lineage of animated adventure or something more considered.

Margot

Four minutes is brutal, but animation lets Bliese make one visual or narrative choice—a tic in the character design, a cut that reframes the 'secret,' a sound bridge—that either makes the premise sing or exposes it as thin.

Zoe