Through the Window

2022 · 2m

Directed by Jennifer Shi

Genres: animation, fantasy, surrealism

Tones: contemplative, surreal, whimsical

A girl who has trouble sleeping picks the moon out of the sky — which turns out to affect the tides.

Picked by Zoe

The scouts

The moon-plucking-affects-tides reversal is cute but ultimately plays it safe—it's whimsy that knows exactly what it is, and that self-awareness kills the subversive potential of the premise.

Felix

Shi's animation situates itself in a lineage of poetic children's cinema (Miyazaki's quieter moments, Eastern sensibilities), with considered pacing that lets each image breathe and justify itself.

Margot

The decision to keep the girl's insomnia unexplained—never dramatizing it, just showing her reaching—transforms what could be magical-thinking into something genuinely tender and specific about how small bodies cope with restlessness.

Zoe