"When I Go ... That's It!"
1972 · 11m · Canada
Directed by Colin Low, George C. Stoney, Ron Alexander, Dennis Sawyer
Genres: documentary
Tones: contemplative
Former fisherman Billy Crane, now working an industrial job with regular hours in Brampton, Ontario, explains why he left Fogo Island. He insists he has no regrets about the move or the life he left behind.
Picked by Margot
The scouts
A guy insists he has no regrets about abandoning his entire way of life—except the whole film is basically him talking himself into it, which is way more interesting than the premise wants to admit, and that contradiction is doing all the real work.
Low and Stoney's restraint here is masterful: they let the gaps between what Billy says and what his silences suggest become the actual subject, a formal strategy rooted in the direct cinema tradition that transforms a simple premise into something genuinely ambiguous.
The decision to never cut away from Billy's face while he speaks—to trust the documentary subject over montage or reaction—means every micro-expression of doubt registers as its own confession, and that single commitment to observation elevates the entire piece.